{"comparison_schema":"nmd-vcell-comparison-object/1.1","comparison_id":"CMP-20260726-38C8401BDC25","key":"mixed","title":"Mixed action and gap comparison","payload_sha256":"38c8401bdc25bcfacbc04c22faac33e686b93f737feb9695cd88b10b97a120f0","resource_release":"v1.0.0-database-resource","schema_version":"1.1","research_object_schema":"1.3","evidence_freeze":"2026-07-25","interface_build":"EA-20260802-46","object_creation_build":"EA-20260730-42","generated_at":"2026-07-26T00:00:00.000Z","original_input_identifiers":["ZNF133","WDR4","GFOD2","INTS13"],"identifier_mapping":{"source":{"licence":"CC0","retrieved_at":"2026-07-25","sha256":"41fe4d55110b22ac3a4c2579d281b0fcf51f18c0b622b0f88f45d49bb2c0d9fb","snapshot_sha256":"272ebb642268184c6a4baeb0de9ffc6a87ea1baf96f2a286fcb07d78f1dd93c5","url":"https://storage.googleapis.com/public-download-files/hgnc/tsv/tsv/hgnc_complete_set.txt"},"retrieved_at":"2026-07-25"},"ranking_generated":false,"lifecycle":{"state":"RELEASED","revision":1,"immutable":true,"registered_at":"2026-07-26T00:00:00.000Z","supersedes":null},"rows":[{"input_identifiers":["ZNF133"],"normalized_symbol":"ZNF133","mapping_status":"approved_symbol","mapping_source":"HGNC HGNC:12917","mapping_candidates":["ZNF133"],"gene":"ZNF133","record":{"gene":"ZNF133","identifiers":{"hgnc_id":"HGNC:12917","ensembl_gene_id":"ENSG00000125846","ncbi_gene_id":7692},"decision":{"current_action":"muscle_assay","current_display_label":"Muscle-context assay","formal_deprioritization":false},"highest_supported_level":"L2_observed_same_context_perturbation","highest_assessed_level":"L3a_external_context_screen","dmd_context":{"integrated_prior_direction":"up","source_direction_state":"conflicted","source_direction_agreement":{"agreeing_sources":3,"assessed_sources":4,"directional_sources":4,"proportion":0.75},"variant_stability_state":"sign_varied_across_variants","variant_count":9,"evidence_module_memberships":["direction_conflicted"],"statistical_support_state":"direction_only_no_significant_context_rows","coverage_state":"4_of_4_sources","integration_method":"median signed score across significant context rows when present, otherwise across all available context rows; source-level directions are audited separately","uncertainty_state":"direction_conflict_retained","conflict_reason":"3 source(s) positive and 1 source(s) negative","integrated_direction_is_prior_not_ground_truth":true,"consensus_direction":"up_in_dmd","consensus_direction_deprecation":{"deprecated":true,"replacement":"integrated_prior_direction","policy":"retained for one schema cycle; do not interpret as study consensus"}},"evidence_status":{"resource_record":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported"},"observed_hepg2_perturbation":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported","observed_cells":84},"internal_model_support":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported_with_limits","target_specific_predictive_support":"not_supported","ood_status":"not_assessed","context":"same_processed_hepg2_dataset"},"external_context_screen":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"context_evidence_present","hit":false,"effect_size":-0.003533,"fdr":0.999999,"context":"GSE293514_myoblast_fusion_screen","interpretation":"assessed_no_current_hit"},"independent_perturbation_replication":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"dmd_muscle_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"functional_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"therapeutic_utility":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"}},"context_metrics":{"skeletal_muscle_median_tpm":4.55781,"moderate_dependency_flag":false},"evidence_gaps":{"decision_blocking_gap":{"code":"GAP-02","label":"Independent muscle-context perturbation is absent"},"highest_missing_evidence_layer":"L4_dmd_functional_validation","secondary_gaps":["GAP-03 DMD-relevant functional validation","GAP-07 independent replication"]},"has_detailed_audit_record":true}},{"input_identifiers":["WDR4"],"normalized_symbol":"WDR4","mapping_status":"approved_symbol","mapping_source":"HGNC HGNC:12756","mapping_candidates":["WDR4"],"gene":"WDR4","record":{"gene":"WDR4","identifiers":{"hgnc_id":"HGNC:12756","ensembl_gene_id":"ENSG00000160193","ncbi_gene_id":10785},"decision":{"current_action":"risk_review","current_display_label":"Risk/context review","formal_deprioritization":false},"highest_supported_level":"L2_observed_same_context_perturbation","highest_assessed_level":"L3a_external_context_screen","dmd_context":{"integrated_prior_direction":"up","source_direction_state":"consistent_up","source_direction_agreement":{"agreeing_sources":4,"assessed_sources":4,"directional_sources":4,"proportion":1},"variant_stability_state":"sign_varied_across_variants","variant_count":9,"evidence_module_memberships":["exploratory_multisource_core"],"statistical_support_state":"direction_only_no_significant_context_rows","coverage_state":"4_of_4_sources","integration_method":"median signed score across significant context rows when present, otherwise across all available context rows; source-level directions are audited separately","uncertainty_state":"direction_consistent_not_formal_meta_analysis","conflict_reason":null,"integrated_direction_is_prior_not_ground_truth":true,"consensus_direction":"up_in_dmd","consensus_direction_deprecation":{"deprecated":true,"replacement":"integrated_prior_direction","policy":"retained for one schema cycle; do not interpret as study consensus"}},"evidence_status":{"resource_record":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported"},"observed_hepg2_perturbation":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported","observed_cells":108},"internal_model_support":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported_with_limits","target_specific_predictive_support":"not_supported","ood_status":"not_assessed","context":"same_processed_hepg2_dataset"},"external_context_screen":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"context_evidence_present","hit":false,"effect_size":-0.010262,"fdr":0.999999,"context":"GSE293514_myoblast_fusion_screen","interpretation":"assessed_no_current_hit"},"independent_perturbation_replication":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"dmd_muscle_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"functional_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"therapeutic_utility":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"}},"context_metrics":{"skeletal_muscle_median_tpm":4.15911,"moderate_dependency_flag":true},"evidence_gaps":{"decision_blocking_gap":{"code":"GAP-08","label":"Safety and dependency context blocks escalation"},"highest_missing_evidence_layer":"L4_dmd_functional_validation","secondary_gaps":["GAP-02 independent muscle-context perturbation","GAP-03 DMD-relevant functional validation","GAP-07 independent replication"]},"has_detailed_audit_record":true}},{"input_identifiers":["GFOD2"],"normalized_symbol":"GFOD2","mapping_status":"approved_symbol","mapping_source":"HGNC HGNC:28159","mapping_candidates":["GFOD2"],"gene":"GFOD2","record":{"gene":"GFOD2","identifiers":{"hgnc_id":"HGNC:28159","ensembl_gene_id":"ENSG00000141098","ncbi_gene_id":81577},"decision":{"current_action":"hold_pending_external_audit","current_display_label":"Provisional hold · external report not yet audited","formal_deprioritization":false},"highest_supported_level":"L2_observed_same_context_perturbation","highest_assessed_level":"L2_observed_same_context_perturbation","dmd_context":{"integrated_prior_direction":"up","source_direction_state":"conflicted","source_direction_agreement":{"agreeing_sources":2,"assessed_sources":4,"directional_sources":4,"proportion":0.5},"variant_stability_state":"sign_varied_across_variants","variant_count":9,"evidence_module_memberships":["direction_conflicted"],"statistical_support_state":"direction_only_no_significant_context_rows","coverage_state":"4_of_4_sources","integration_method":"median signed score across significant context rows when present, otherwise across all available context rows; source-level directions are audited separately","uncertainty_state":"direction_conflict_retained","conflict_reason":"2 source(s) positive and 2 source(s) negative","integrated_direction_is_prior_not_ground_truth":true,"consensus_direction":"up_in_dmd","consensus_direction_deprecation":{"deprecated":true,"replacement":"integrated_prior_direction","policy":"retained for one schema cycle; do not interpret as study consensus"}},"evidence_status":{"resource_record":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported"},"observed_hepg2_perturbation":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported","observed_cells":127},"internal_model_support":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported_with_limits","target_specific_predictive_support":"not_supported","ood_status":"not_assessed","context":"same_processed_hepg2_dataset"},"external_context_screen":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed","hit":null},"independent_perturbation_replication":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"dmd_muscle_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"functional_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"therapeutic_utility":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"}},"context_metrics":{"skeletal_muscle_median_tpm":2.94732,"moderate_dependency_flag":false},"evidence_gaps":{"decision_blocking_gap":{"code":"GAP-09","label":"External quantitative evidence has not been imported and audited"},"highest_missing_evidence_layer":"L4_dmd_functional_validation","secondary_gaps":["GAP-02 independent muscle-context perturbation","GAP-03 DMD-relevant functional validation","GAP-07 independent replication"]},"has_detailed_audit_record":true}},{"input_identifiers":["INTS13"],"normalized_symbol":"INTS13","mapping_status":"approved_symbol","mapping_source":"HGNC HGNC:20174","mapping_candidates":["INTS13"],"gene":"INTS13","record":{"gene":"INTS13","identifiers":{"hgnc_id":"HGNC:20174","ensembl_gene_id":"ENSG00000064102","ncbi_gene_id":55726},"decision":{"current_action":"risk_review","current_display_label":"Risk/context review","formal_deprioritization":false},"highest_supported_level":"L2_observed_same_context_perturbation","highest_assessed_level":"L2_observed_same_context_perturbation","dmd_context":{"integrated_prior_direction":"up","source_direction_state":"consistent_up","source_direction_agreement":{"agreeing_sources":4,"assessed_sources":4,"directional_sources":4,"proportion":1},"variant_stability_state":"sign_varied_across_variants","variant_count":9,"evidence_module_memberships":["exploratory_multisource_core"],"statistical_support_state":"direction_only_no_significant_context_rows","coverage_state":"4_of_4_sources","integration_method":"median signed score across significant context rows when present, otherwise across all available context rows; source-level directions are audited separately","uncertainty_state":"direction_consistent_not_formal_meta_analysis","conflict_reason":null,"integrated_direction_is_prior_not_ground_truth":true,"consensus_direction":"up_in_dmd","consensus_direction_deprecation":{"deprecated":true,"replacement":"integrated_prior_direction","policy":"retained for one schema cycle; do not interpret as study consensus"}},"evidence_status":{"resource_record":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported"},"observed_hepg2_perturbation":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported","observed_cells":157},"internal_model_support":{"assessment_status":"assessed","support_status":"supported_with_limits","target_specific_predictive_support":"not_supported","ood_status":"not_assessed","context":"same_processed_hepg2_dataset"},"external_context_screen":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed","hit":null},"independent_perturbation_replication":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"dmd_muscle_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"functional_validation":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"},"therapeutic_utility":{"assessment_status":"not_assessed"}},"context_metrics":{"skeletal_muscle_median_tpm":10.9911,"moderate_dependency_flag":true},"evidence_gaps":{"decision_blocking_gap":{"code":"GAP-08","label":"Safety and dependency context blocks escalation"},"highest_missing_evidence_layer":"L4_dmd_functional_validation","secondary_gaps":["GAP-02 independent muscle-context perturbation","GAP-03 DMD-relevant functional validation","GAP-07 independent replication"]},"has_detailed_audit_record":true}}],"claim_boundary":"This comparison preserves evidence dimensions and missingness. It does not create a composite score, ranking, causal claim or therapeutic recommendation.","stable_url":"comparison/CMP-20260726-38C8401BDC25/"}