{
  "schema": "nmd-vcell-claim-evidence-graph/1.0",
  "updated": "2026-09-15",
  "direction_rule": "Edges point from a claim to the evidence, dependency, process or consumer that qualifies its use.",
  "node_count": 18,
  "edge_count": 32,
  "node_types": {
    "Claim": 6,
    "Consumer": 4,
    "EvidenceObject": 7,
    "Process": 1
  },
  "nodes": [
    {
      "node_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "node_type": "Claim",
      "label": "DMD candidate outcome boundary",
      "state": "MISSING",
      "public_path": "/resource/claims/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "REGISTRY:CANDIDATE_DECISIONS:CURRENT",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "REGISTRY:CANDIDATE_DECISIONS:CURRENT",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v1.1/candidate_decision_registry.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "REGISTRY:REGISTERED_STUDIES:CURRENT",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "REGISTRY:REGISTERED_STUDIES:CURRENT",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v1.1/registered_studies.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "REGISTRY:EXPERIMENTAL_OUTCOMES:CURRENT",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "REGISTRY:EXPERIMENTAL_OUTCOMES:CURRENT",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v1.1/experimental_outcomes.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "SURFACE:DMD_WORKSPACE",
      "node_type": "Consumer",
      "label": "SURFACE:DMD_WORKSPACE",
      "public_path": "/resource/disease/dmd/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "SURFACE:EVIDENCE_STATUS",
      "node_type": "Consumer",
      "label": "SURFACE:EVIDENCE_STATUS",
      "public_path": "/resource/evidence-status/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "node_type": "Process",
      "label": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v2/claim_registry.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "CLAIM:P59:TRANSPORT_AND_PLATES_COMPLETE:V1",
      "node_type": "Claim",
      "label": "P59 transport and plate-statistics completion",
      "state": "OBSERVED_ENGINEERING",
      "public_path": "/resource/claims/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "STATUS:SUPPORT_AWARE:CURRENT",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "STATUS:SUPPORT_AWARE:CURRENT",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v1.1/support_aware_status.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "REGISTRY:PUBLICATION_PACKAGES:V2",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "REGISTRY:PUBLICATION_PACKAGES:V2",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v2/publication_packages.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "SURFACE:SUPPORT_AWARE",
      "node_type": "Consumer",
      "label": "SURFACE:SUPPORT_AWARE",
      "public_path": "/resource/support-aware"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "node_type": "Claim",
      "label": "P59 primary scorer failure",
      "state": "FAILURE_RETAINED",
      "public_path": "/resource/claims/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "PACKAGE:SCIENCE_ADVANCES:P59",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "PACKAGE:SCIENCE_ADVANCES:P59",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v2/publication_packages.json"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "SURFACE:PUBLICATIONS",
      "node_type": "Consumer",
      "label": "SURFACE:PUBLICATIONS",
      "public_path": "/resource/publications/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "node_type": "Claim",
      "label": "P59 target result remains absent",
      "state": "MISSING",
      "public_path": "/resource/claims/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "node_type": "Claim",
      "label": "Failure ranking and utility remain distinct",
      "state": "BOUNDED_INTERPRETATION",
      "public_path": "/resource/claims/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "CLAIM:NAR:CURATED_V08_WORKING_STATE:V1",
      "node_type": "Claim",
      "label": "NAR curated v08 working-package state",
      "state": "WORKING",
      "public_path": "/resource/claims/"
    },
    {
      "node_id": "REGISTRY:NAR:PUBLICATION_PACKAGE:V1",
      "node_type": "EvidenceObject",
      "label": "REGISTRY:NAR:PUBLICATION_PACKAGE:V1",
      "public_path": "/resource/api/v1.1/publication_package_registry.json"
    }
  ],
  "edges": [
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:001",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "target_id": "REGISTRY:CANDIDATE_DECISIONS:CURRENT",
      "relation": "RECORDS_ABSENCE"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:002",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "target_id": "REGISTRY:REGISTERED_STUDIES:CURRENT",
      "relation": "RECORDS_ABSENCE"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:003",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "target_id": "REGISTRY:EXPERIMENTAL_OUTCOMES:CURRENT",
      "relation": "RECORDS_ABSENCE"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:004",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:DMD_WORKSPACE",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:005",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:EVIDENCE_STATUS",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:006",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:DMD:CANDIDATE_OUTCOME_BOUNDARY:V1",
      "target_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "relation": "GENERATED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:007",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:TRANSPORT_AND_PLATES_COMPLETE:V1",
      "target_id": "STATUS:SUPPORT_AWARE:CURRENT",
      "relation": "SUPPORTS"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:008",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:TRANSPORT_AND_PLATES_COMPLETE:V1",
      "target_id": "REGISTRY:PUBLICATION_PACKAGES:V2",
      "relation": "LIMITS"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:009",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:TRANSPORT_AND_PLATES_COMPLETE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:SUPPORT_AWARE",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:010",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:TRANSPORT_AND_PLATES_COMPLETE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:EVIDENCE_STATUS",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:011",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:TRANSPORT_AND_PLATES_COMPLETE:V1",
      "target_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "relation": "GENERATED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:012",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "target_id": "STATUS:SUPPORT_AWARE:CURRENT",
      "relation": "RECORDS_FAILURE"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:013",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "target_id": "PACKAGE:SCIENCE_ADVANCES:P59",
      "relation": "LIMITS"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:014",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:SUPPORT_AWARE",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:015",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:PUBLICATIONS",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:016",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "target_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "relation": "GENERATED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:017",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "target_id": "STATUS:SUPPORT_AWARE:CURRENT",
      "relation": "RECORDS_ABSENCE"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:018",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:SUPPORT_AWARE",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:019",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:EVIDENCE_STATUS",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:020",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "target_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "relation": "GENERATED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:021",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "target_id": "CLAIM:P59:PRIMARY_SCORER_FAILURE:V1",
      "relation": "MISSING_BECAUSE"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:022",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "target_id": "STATUS:SUPPORT_AWARE:CURRENT",
      "relation": "SUPPORTS"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:023",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "target_id": "PACKAGE:SCIENCE_ADVANCES:P59",
      "relation": "LIMITS"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:024",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:SUPPORT_AWARE",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:025",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "target_id": "PACKAGE:SCIENCE_ADVANCES:P59",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:026",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "target_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "relation": "GENERATED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:027",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:SUPPORT_AWARE:RANKING_UTILITY_SEPARATION:V1",
      "target_id": "CLAIM:P59:NO_TARGET_SCORE:V1",
      "relation": "LIMITED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:028",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:NAR:CURATED_V08_WORKING_STATE:V1",
      "target_id": "REGISTRY:NAR:PUBLICATION_PACKAGE:V1",
      "relation": "DEFINES_MEMBERSHIP"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:029",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:NAR:CURATED_V08_WORKING_STATE:V1",
      "target_id": "REGISTRY:PUBLICATION_PACKAGES:V2",
      "relation": "LIMITS"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:030",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:NAR:CURATED_V08_WORKING_STATE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:PUBLICATIONS",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:031",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:NAR:CURATED_V08_WORKING_STATE:V1",
      "target_id": "SURFACE:EVIDENCE_STATUS",
      "relation": "USED_BY"
    },
    {
      "edge_id": "EDGE:CLAIM_GRAPH:032",
      "source_id": "CLAIM:NAR:CURATED_V08_WORKING_STATE:V1",
      "target_id": "PROCESS:CLAIM_REGISTRY_BUILD:V196",
      "relation": "GENERATED_BY"
    }
  ],
  "graph_sha256": "deb5fca0e460c601b8208e97cea803c2f743cf4e00922d235a2985539c75d8a0"
}