{ "registry_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run-registry/1.0", "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_count": 6, "completed_run_count": 6, "calibrated_dmd_run_count": 0, "model_capability_map_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-capability-map/1.0", "model_capability_map_url": "api/v1.1/model_capability_map.json", "capability_map_linkage": [ { "capability_id": "CAP-MODEL-SAME-ASSAY-RESPONSE", "lane": "Same-assay response baseline", "model_ids": [ "NMDVCELL-RIDGE-SAFE-2.3" ], "model_run_ids": [ "MRUN-RIDGE-SAFE-2.3-G0-REPEATED-FOLD" ], "handoff_route": "/resource/model-run/mrun-ridge-safe-2-3-g0-repeated-fold/" }, { "capability_id": "CAP-MODEL-EXTERNAL-TRANSFER-COMPARATOR", "lane": "External transfer and advanced comparators", "model_ids": [ "NMDVCELL-TRANSFER-DIAGNOSTIC-1.0" ], "model_run_ids": [ "MRUN-TRANSFER-DIAGNOSTIC-1.0-G1", "MRUN-GEARS-0.1.2-FIVE-SEED-20260713", "MRUN-SCGPT-0.2.5-FIVE-SEED-20260714", "MRUN-TXPERT-CONFIG-GAT-SEED-20260712", "MRUN-MORPH-DEPMAP25Q3-VALIDATION-20260722" ], "handoff_route": "/resource/benchmarks/" }, { "capability_id": "CAP-MODEL-DMD-PERTURBATION-RESPONSE", "lane": "DMD perturbation response", "model_ids": [ "NMDVCELL-DMD-TRANSITION-FUTURE", "NMDVCELL-GENE-CHEMICAL-BRIDGE-FUTURE" ], "model_run_ids": [], "handoff_route": "/resource/dmd-outcome-pilot/" }, { "capability_id": "CAP-MODEL-PATIENT-FUNCTIONAL-GENERALIZATION", "lane": "Patient and functional generalization", "model_ids": [ "NMDVCELL-PATIENT-TRAJECTORY-FUTURE" ], "model_run_ids": [], "handoff_route": "/resource/research-program/" } ], "decision_counts": { "RETAINED_LIMITED_BASELINE": 1, "UNSUPPORTED_TRANSFER": 1, "OFFICIAL_NEGATIVE_CONTROL": 2, "ADVANCEMENT_GATE_FAILED": 1, "SCIENTIFIC_NO_GO_TEST_SEALED": 1 }, "required_provenance_fields": [ "code_revision", "container_digest", "data_digests", "split_id", "seeds", "source_report_path", "source_report_sha256" ], "migration_policy": "Completed historical runs remain registered even when provenance fields are missing. Missing fields are explicit and block stronger reproducibility claims; they do not turn a completed negative run into an unexecuted architecture.", "records": [ { "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_id": "MRUN-RIDGE-SAFE-2.3-G0-REPEATED-FOLD", "model_id": "NMDVCELL-RIDGE-SAFE-2.3", "model_name": "Same-context ridge residual baseline", "model_version": "ridge-safe-v2.3", "run_role": "PERMANENT_BASELINE", "execution_status": "COMPLETED", "decision_state": "RETAINED_LIMITED_BASELINE", "completed_at": null, "completion_date_status": "NOT_EXPLICIT_IN_MIGRATED_SUMMARY", "biological_context": "Processed HepG2 CRISPRi perturbation-response substrate", "task_id": "G0", "data_release": "NMDVCELL-HEPG2-CRISPRI", "split_id": "repeated-fold-v2.2", "seeds": [], "seed_status": "FOLD_SUMMARY_MIGRATED_WITHOUT_SEED_LEDGER", "provenance": { "code_revision": null, "code_revision_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_MIGRATED_SUMMARY", "container_digest": null, "container_digest_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_MIGRATED_SUMMARY", "data_digests": [], "runtime": "Current released same-context benchmark object", "source_report_path": null, "source_report_sha256": null }, "metrics": { "mean_model_rmse": 0.11750674428366534, "mean_train_mean_rmse": 0.11797301624780862, "mean_zero_rmse": 0.12379862654747228 }, "baseline_comparison": "Small mean-RMSE improvement over train mean; raw response direction remains unsupported.", "gate": { "decision": "LIMITED_PASS_SAME_CONTEXT_ONLY", "reason": "Useful as a same-assay control, not as a transport or DMD response model.", "next_action": "Retain permanently on every compatible holdout." }, "verification": "Released benchmark summary and Evidence Atlas invariants.", "source_artifacts": [ "/resource/api/v1.1/benchmark_summary.json", "/resource/benchmarks" ], "promoted_to_current_model": true, "claim_boundary": { "calibrated_dmd_prediction": false, "dmd_disease_response_prediction": false, "therapeutic_or_clinical_use": false }, "stable_url": "/resource/model-run/mrun-ridge-safe-2-3-g0-repeated-fold/", "json_url": "/resource/api/v1.1/model-runs/mrun-ridge-safe-2-3-g0-repeated-fold.json" }, { "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_id": "MRUN-TRANSFER-DIAGNOSTIC-1.0-G1", "model_id": "NMDVCELL-TRANSFER-DIAGNOSTIC-1.0", "model_name": "External perturbation transfer diagnostic", "model_version": "1.0", "run_role": "TRANSFER_DIAGNOSTIC", "execution_status": "COMPLETED", "decision_state": "UNSUPPORTED_TRANSFER", "completed_at": null, "completion_date_status": "NOT_EXPLICIT_IN_MIGRATED_MODEL_CARD", "biological_context": "HepG2 response substrate evaluated against a frozen 55-target external aggregate", "task_id": "G1", "data_release": "FROZEN-55-TARGET-EXTERNAL-AGGREGATE", "split_id": "external-aggregate-diagnostic-v1", "seeds": [], "seed_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_MIGRATED_MODEL_CARD", "provenance": { "code_revision": null, "code_revision_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_MIGRATED_MODEL_CARD", "container_digest": null, "container_digest_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_MIGRATED_MODEL_CARD", "data_digests": [], "runtime": "Migrated from the current executed model card", "source_report_path": null, "source_report_sha256": null }, "metrics": {}, "baseline_comparison": "The current response substrate did not transfer directionally to the external aggregate.", "gate": { "decision": "FAIL", "reason": "Directional transfer was unsupported.", "next_action": "Require harmonized cell-level outcome and a preregistered external estimator." }, "verification": "Current v1.1 model card migration; missing provenance fields remain explicit.", "source_artifacts": [ "/resource/api/v1.1/model_registry.json" ], "promoted_to_current_model": true, "claim_boundary": { "calibrated_dmd_prediction": false, "dmd_disease_response_prediction": false, "therapeutic_or_clinical_use": false }, "stable_url": "/resource/model-run/mrun-transfer-diagnostic-1-0-g1/", "json_url": "/resource/api/v1.1/model-runs/mrun-transfer-diagnostic-1-0-g1.json" }, { "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_id": "MRUN-GEARS-0.1.2-FIVE-SEED-20260713", "model_id": "EXTERNAL-GEARS-0.1.2", "model_name": "GEARS", "model_version": "0.1.2", "run_role": "OFFICIAL_NEGATIVE_CONTROL", "execution_status": "COMPLETED", "decision_state": "OFFICIAL_NEGATIVE_CONTROL", "completed_at": "2026-07-13", "completion_date_status": "FROZEN_COMPLETION_NOTE", "biological_context": "Processed HepG2 CRISPRi perturbation-response substrate", "task_id": "G0", "data_release": "NMDVCELL-HEPG2-CRISPRI", "split_id": "five-frozen-target-splits-20260712-20260716", "seeds": [ "20260712", "20260713", "20260714", "20260715", "20260716" ], "seed_status": "COMPLETE", "provenance": { "code_revision": null, "code_revision_status": "VERSION_RECORDED_COMMIT_NOT_IN_COMPLETION_NOTE", "container_digest": null, "container_digest_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_COMPLETION_NOTE", "data_digests": [], "runtime": "PyTorch 2.5.1+cu121; NVIDIA V100 32GB; 20 epochs per seed", "source_report_path": "reports/OFFICIAL_GEARS_COMPLETION_20260713.md", "source_report_sha256": "3252f0e8e0d52e9770086027d6f80389e2b75b2fa93ca980328191149f764ab3" }, "metrics": { "test_gene_counts": [ 534, 534, 526, 532, 535 ] }, "baseline_comparison": "Failed paired RMSE and raw directional support in all five splits; ridge won every direct same-coverage comparison after Holm correction.", "gate": { "decision": "FAIL", "reason": "No deep-model superiority over the permanent ridge baseline.", "next_action": "Retain as an official negative control; do not promote a superiority claim." }, "verification": "Five-seed completion note and released per-seed summary, gates and same-coverage comparison.", "source_artifacts": [ "/resource/api/v1/official_gears_summary.json", "/resource/api/v1/official_gears_gates.json", "/resource/api/v1/official_gears_vs_ridge.json" ], "promoted_to_current_model": false, "claim_boundary": { "calibrated_dmd_prediction": false, "dmd_disease_response_prediction": false, "therapeutic_or_clinical_use": false }, "stable_url": "/resource/model-run/mrun-gears-0-1-2-five-seed-20260713/", "json_url": "/resource/api/v1.1/model-runs/mrun-gears-0-1-2-five-seed-20260713.json" }, { "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_id": "MRUN-SCGPT-0.2.5-FIVE-SEED-20260714", "model_id": "EXTERNAL-SCGPT-0.2.5", "model_name": "scGPT", "model_version": "0.2.5", "run_role": "OFFICIAL_NEGATIVE_CONTROL", "execution_status": "COMPLETED", "decision_state": "OFFICIAL_NEGATIVE_CONTROL", "completed_at": "2026-07-14", "completion_date_status": "FROZEN_COMPLETION_NOTE", "biological_context": "Processed HepG2 CRISPRi perturbation-response substrate with checkpoint-supported gene coverage", "task_id": "G0", "data_release": "NMDVCELL-HEPG2-CRISPRI", "split_id": "five-frozen-checkpoint-supported-splits-20260712-20260716", "seeds": [ "20260712", "20260713", "20260714", "20260715", "20260716" ], "seed_status": "COMPLETE", "provenance": { "code_revision": null, "code_revision_status": "VERSION_RECORDED_COMMIT_NOT_IN_COMPLETION_NOTE", "container_digest": null, "container_digest_status": "NOT_RECORDED_IN_COMPLETION_NOTE", "data_digests": [], "runtime": "PyTorch 2.5.1+cu121; NVIDIA V100 32GB; 15 epochs per seed", "source_report_path": "reports/OFFICIAL_SCGPT_COMPLETION_20260714.md", "source_report_sha256": "2e5f01b877552572981d34aef2b0ccc0c45be8928c4b61dffe126b66eb69f3db" }, "metrics": { "checkpoint_supported_test_gene_counts": [ 63, 67, 55, 62, 46 ] }, "baseline_comparison": "Failed paired RMSE and raw directional support in all five splits; RMSE was higher than same-coverage ridge in every split.", "gate": { "decision": "FAIL", "reason": "The completed checkpoint-supported run did not support foundation-model superiority.", "next_action": "Retain as an official negative control with its restricted coverage visible." }, "verification": "Five-seed completion note and released per-seed summary, gates and same-coverage comparison.", "source_artifacts": [ "/resource/api/v1/official_scgpt_summary.json", "/resource/api/v1/official_scgpt_gates.json", "/resource/api/v1/official_scgpt_vs_ridge.json" ], "promoted_to_current_model": false, "claim_boundary": { "calibrated_dmd_prediction": false, "dmd_disease_response_prediction": false, "therapeutic_or_clinical_use": false }, "stable_url": "/resource/model-run/mrun-scgpt-0-2-5-five-seed-20260714/", "json_url": "/resource/api/v1.1/model-runs/mrun-scgpt-0-2-5-five-seed-20260714.json" }, { "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_id": "MRUN-TXPERT-CONFIG-GAT-SEED-20260712", "model_id": "EXTERNAL-TXPERT-CONFIG-GAT-PUBLIC-STRING", "model_name": "TxPert public-STRING config-gat", "model_version": "source-08d82ee", "run_role": "PREREGISTERED_ADVANCED_COMPARATOR", "execution_status": "COMPLETED", "decision_state": "ADVANCEMENT_GATE_FAILED", "completed_at": "2026-07-21", "completion_date_status": "FROZEN_EXECUTION_REPORT", "biological_context": "Processed HepG2 CRISPRi perturbation-response substrate", "task_id": "G0", "data_release": "NMDVCELL-HEPG2-CRISPRI-TXPERT-ADAPTER-V26", "split_id": "txpert-v26-frozen-seed-20260712", "seeds": [ "20260712" ], "seed_status": "FIRST_SEED_COMPLETE_REMAINING_CONFIRMATORY_SEEDS_LOCKED", "provenance": { "code_revision": "08d82eea86746b044cf7531f4ec8c5f60e1cb73f", "code_revision_status": "PINNED_CLEAN_OFFICIAL_SOURCE", "container_digest": null, "container_digest_status": "RUNTIME_RECORDED_CONTAINER_DIGEST_NOT_FROZEN", "data_digests": [], "runtime": "Official-width config-gat with public STRING; 20 epochs; V100 recovery evaluation made zero parameter updates", "source_report_path": "reports/V26_MULTIMODEL_VIRTUAL_CELL_EXECUTION_REPORT_20260721.md", "source_report_sha256": "3b09c036563b4039c5d3061212522c6cbad41990d320a5bc32ebb89838edb8fc" }, "metrics": { "held_out_conditions": 534, "global_delta_rmse": 0.115092, "median_delta_rmse": 0.097833, "median_delta_cosine": 0.346196, "top1_retrieval_fraction": 0.02809, "top5_retrieval_fraction": 0.09176, "train_mean_median_delta_cosine": 0.373307 }, "baseline_comparison": "Improved RMSE and retrieval over simple controls but missed the preregistered median-delta-cosine gate against train mean.", "gate": { "decision": "FAIL", "reason": "Median delta cosine 0.346196 was below the train-mean control at 0.373307.", "next_action": "Do not run the remaining confirmatory seeds without a new preregistration and untouched evaluation set." }, "verification": "Independent recomputation passed 130/130 checks; the advancement gate remained failed.", "source_artifacts": [], "promoted_to_current_model": false, "claim_boundary": { "calibrated_dmd_prediction": false, "dmd_disease_response_prediction": false, "therapeutic_or_clinical_use": false }, "stable_url": "/resource/model-run/mrun-txpert-config-gat-seed-20260712/", "json_url": "/resource/api/v1.1/model-runs/mrun-txpert-config-gat-seed-20260712.json" }, { "run_schema": "nmd-vcell-model-run/1.0", "interface_build": "EA-20260817-57", "resource_release": "v1.2.0-measured-dmd-evidence", "evidence_freeze": "2026-08-03", "run_id": "MRUN-MORPH-DEPMAP25Q3-VALIDATION-20260722", "model_id": "EXTERNAL-MORPH-1AD06D4", "model_name": "MORPH DepMap-25Q3 validation pilot", "model_version": "source-1ad06d4", "run_role": "VALIDATION_ONLY_NEGATIVE_CONTROL", "execution_status": "COMPLETED", "decision_state": "SCIENTIFIC_NO_GO_TEST_SEALED", "completed_at": "2026-07-22", "completion_date_status": "FROZEN_VALIDATION_REPORT", "biological_context": "Deterministic HepG2 perturbation pilot with DepMap Public 25Q3 gene embeddings", "task_id": "G0-VALIDATION-PILOT", "data_release": "DEPMAP-25Q3-MORPH-PILOT", "split_id": "64-train-16-validation-v27-test-sealed", "seeds": [ "20260722" ], "seed_status": "VALIDATION_COMPLETE_TEST_NOT_OPENED", "provenance": { "code_revision": "1ad06d4591434cc4ab03c12c461fe0d80b087b11", "code_revision_status": "PINNED_CLEAN_OFFICIAL_SOURCE", "container_digest": null, "container_digest_status": "RUNTIME_RECORDED_CONTAINER_DIGEST_NOT_FROZEN", "data_digests": [ "31bcf5d27f1fe3fcf6c5ff4f2aae8695ee1b03956b4bef786a49633055cc5f75", "08efa31e997358e333ead55ed21cbf0f643cfafe15b38a242acaaa11eb0a7962" ], "runtime": "PyTorch 2.5.1+cu121; NVIDIA V100 32GB; 10 epochs", "source_report_path": "reports/V27_MORPH_DEPMAP25Q3_TRAIN_VALIDATION_PILOT_20260722.md", "source_report_sha256": "7a0cb26b971fc5b6fd0381890bb773548265acd71d8343c90671b80069402de1" }, "metrics": { "validation_conditions": 16, "morph_delta_mse": 0.014162, "train_mean_delta_mse": 0.010558, "zero_delta_mse": 0.014293, "relative_worsening_vs_train_mean": 0.3413 }, "baseline_comparison": "Reduced MSE by 0.92% versus zero but was 34.13% worse than train mean; beat train mean on only 2 of 16 validation conditions.", "gate": { "decision": "NO_GO", "reason": "Engineering passed, but the model did not beat the simple train-mean baseline.", "next_action": "Keep the v27 test partition sealed; any revision needs a fresh validation contract." }, "verification": "Independent verifier reproduced the checkpoint, sampler state and every condition-level metric.", "source_artifacts": [], "promoted_to_current_model": false, "claim_boundary": { "calibrated_dmd_prediction": false, "dmd_disease_response_prediction": false, "therapeutic_or_clinical_use": false }, "stable_url": "/resource/model-run/mrun-morph-depmap25q3-validation-20260722/", "json_url": "/resource/api/v1.1/model-runs/mrun-morph-depmap25q3-validation-20260722.json" } ], "boundary": "This ledger preserves technical and negative benchmark history. It does not contain a calibrated DMD perturbation-response ModelRun." }