{ "schema": "nmd-vcell-adam10-formal-lock-workbench-v09.1/1.0", "object_id": "WORKBENCH:NMDVCELL-DMD-ADAM10-FORMAL-LOCK:v09.1", "created_at": "2026-09-06", "lifecycle_state": "BROWSER_LOCAL_AUTHORITY_HANDOFF_WORKBENCH_FAIL_CLOSED", "base_lock_id": "NMDVCELL-DMD-ADAM10-FORMAL-OC-LOCK-v08.8-DRAFT", "base_lock_route": "/resource/api/v1.1/adam10_formal_parameter_lock_template_v088.json", "field_count": 39, "evidence_receipt_count_required": 39, "handoff_role_count": 3, "review_assignment_count": 56, "groups": [ { "group_id": "authorities", "label": "Named scientific authorities", "description": "Identify the experimental lead and statistician and record their approval dates.", "field_count": 4 }, { "group_id": "model_pairs", "label": "Named DMD–isogenic model pairs", "description": "Resolve line identity, mutation background, isogenic relationship and myogenic protocol for both independent pairs.", "field_count": 10 }, { "group_id": "primary_molecular_endpoint", "label": "Primary molecular endpoint", "description": "Freeze one molecular endpoint with assay, timepoint, direction and standardization reference.", "field_count": 5 }, { "group_id": "primary_functional_endpoint", "label": "Primary functional endpoint", "description": "Freeze one functional endpoint with assay, timepoint, direction and standardization reference.", "field_count": 5 }, { "group_id": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Operating-characteristic inputs", "description": "Attach endpoint-scale variance and decision-threshold evidence; values must be outcome-blinded.", "field_count": 6 }, { "group_id": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "QC and missingness rules", "description": "Write prospective executable rules, denominators and failure dispositions before assignment generation.", "field_count": 7 }, { "group_id": "outcome_access", "label": "Outcome-access seal", "description": "Name the custodian and record an immutable external freeze receipt before any outcome access.", "field_count": 2 } ], "fields": [ { "field_path": "authorities.experimental_lead_name", "group": "authorities", "label": "Experimental Lead Name", "owner_role": "experimental_lead", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Named approval and checksum-addressed sign-off receipt", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "authorities.experimental_lead_approval_date", "group": "authorities", "label": "Experimental Lead Approval Date", "owner_role": "experimental_lead", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Named approval and checksum-addressed sign-off receipt", "value_kind": "date" }, { "field_path": "authorities.statistician_name", "group": "authorities", "label": "Statistician Name", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Named approval and checksum-addressed sign-off receipt", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "authorities.statistician_approval_date", "group": "authorities", "label": "Statistician Approval Date", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Named approval and checksum-addressed sign-off receipt", "value_kind": "date" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.0.pair_id", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 1 · Pair Id", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.0.dmd_line_identifier", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 1 · Dmd Line Identifier", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.0.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 1 · Isogenic Corrected Line Identifier", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.0.dmd_mutation_background", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 1 · Dmd Mutation Background", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.0.myogenic_protocol_id", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 1 · Myogenic Protocol Id", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.1.pair_id", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 2 · Pair Id", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.1.dmd_line_identifier", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 2 · Dmd Line Identifier", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.1.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 2 · Isogenic Corrected Line Identifier", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.1.dmd_mutation_background", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 2 · Dmd Mutation Background", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "model_pairs.1.myogenic_protocol_id", "group": "model_pairs", "label": "Pair 2 · Myogenic Protocol Id", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_data_steward", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead" ], "evidence_requirement": "Verified line identity, relationship and protocol record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.name", "group": "primary_molecular_endpoint", "label": "Name", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.assay", "group": "primary_molecular_endpoint", "label": "Assay", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.timepoint", "group": "primary_molecular_endpoint", "label": "Timepoint", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.scale_and_direction", "group": "primary_molecular_endpoint", "label": "Scale And Direction", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.standardization_reference", "group": "primary_molecular_endpoint", "label": "Standardization Reference", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.name", "group": "primary_functional_endpoint", "label": "Name", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.assay", "group": "primary_functional_endpoint", "label": "Assay", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.timepoint", "group": "primary_functional_endpoint", "label": "Timepoint", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.scale_and_direction", "group": "primary_functional_endpoint", "label": "Scale And Direction", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.standardization_reference", "group": "primary_functional_endpoint", "label": "Standardization Reference", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Endpoint SOP, units, direction and frozen standardization reference", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.empirical_residual_sd", "group": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Empirical Residual Sd", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Outcome-blinded Stage A estimate or signed scientific justification", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any" }, { "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.between_pair_heterogeneity_sd", "group": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Between Pair Heterogeneity Sd", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Outcome-blinded Stage A estimate or signed scientific justification", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any" }, { "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.delta_delta_variance_multiplier", "group": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Delta Delta Variance Multiplier", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Outcome-blinded Stage A estimate or signed scientific justification", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any" }, { "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.equivalence_margin", "group": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Equivalence Margin", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Outcome-blinded Stage A estimate or signed scientific justification", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any" }, { "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.minimum_guide_retention_probability", "group": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Minimum Guide Retention Probability", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Outcome-blinded Stage A estimate or signed scientific justification", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any", "minimum": 0, "maximum": 1 }, { "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.target_concordant_probability", "group": "operating_characteristic_inputs", "label": "Target Concordant Probability", "owner_role": "statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Outcome-blinded Stage A estimate or signed scientific justification", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any", "minimum": 0, "maximum": 1 }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_complete_guides_per_pair", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Minimum Complete Guides Per Pair", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any" }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_independent_differentiations_per_genotype_pair", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Minimum Independent Differentiations Per Genotype Pair", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "number", "step": "any" }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.engagement_rule", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Engagement Rule", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.positive_control_rule", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Positive Control Rule", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.cell_support_rule", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Cell Support Rule", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.missing_pair_rule", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Missing Pair Rule", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.adverse_effect_rule", "group": "qc_and_missingness", "label": "Adverse Effect Rule", "owner_role": "experimental_lead_and_statistician", "reviewer_roles": [ "experimental_lead", "statistician" ], "evidence_requirement": "Prospective executable rule with denominator, threshold and disposition", "value_kind": "textarea" }, { "field_path": "outcome_access.required_external_freeze_receipt_id", "group": "outcome_access", "label": "Required External Freeze Receipt Id", "owner_role": "outcome_access_custodian", "reviewer_roles": [ "outcome_access_custodian" ], "evidence_requirement": "External freeze receipt and named access-custodian record", "value_kind": "text" }, { "field_path": "outcome_access.access_custodian", "group": "outcome_access", "label": "Access Custodian", "owner_role": "outcome_access_custodian", "reviewer_roles": [ "outcome_access_custodian" ], "evidence_requirement": "External freeze receipt and named access-custodian record", "value_kind": "text" } ], "handoff_roles": [ { "role_id": "experimental_lead", "label": "Experimental lead", "responsibility": "Model identities, endpoint operability and prospective experimental rules.", "field_count": 29, "authority_effect": "REVIEW_ONLY_NO_SIGNATURE" }, { "role_id": "statistician", "label": "Statistician", "responsibility": "Endpoint scales, operating-characteristic inputs, estimands and analysis/QC rules.", "field_count": 25, "authority_effect": "REVIEW_ONLY_NO_SIGNATURE" }, { "role_id": "outcome_access_custodian", "label": "Outcome-access custodian", "responsibility": "External freeze receipt and enforcement of the outcome-access seal.", "field_count": 2, "authority_effect": "REVIEW_ONLY_NO_SIGNATURE" } ], "review_assignments": [ { "assignment_key": "authorities.experimental_lead_name::experimental_lead", "field_path": "authorities.experimental_lead_name", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "authorities.experimental_lead_approval_date::experimental_lead", "field_path": "authorities.experimental_lead_approval_date", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "authorities.statistician_name::statistician", "field_path": "authorities.statistician_name", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "authorities.statistician_approval_date::statistician", "field_path": "authorities.statistician_approval_date", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.0.pair_id::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.0.pair_id", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.0.dmd_line_identifier::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.0.dmd_line_identifier", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.0.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.0.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.0.dmd_mutation_background::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.0.dmd_mutation_background", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.0.myogenic_protocol_id::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.0.myogenic_protocol_id", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.1.pair_id::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.1.pair_id", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.1.dmd_line_identifier::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.1.dmd_line_identifier", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.1.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.1.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.1.dmd_mutation_background::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.1.dmd_mutation_background", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "model_pairs.1.myogenic_protocol_id::experimental_lead", "field_path": "model_pairs.1.myogenic_protocol_id", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.name::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.name", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.name::statistician", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.name", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.assay::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.assay", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.assay::statistician", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.assay", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.timepoint::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.timepoint", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.timepoint::statistician", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.timepoint", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.scale_and_direction::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.scale_and_direction", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.scale_and_direction::statistician", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.scale_and_direction", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.standardization_reference::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.standardization_reference", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_molecular_endpoint.standardization_reference::statistician", "field_path": "primary_molecular_endpoint.standardization_reference", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.name::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.name", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.name::statistician", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.name", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.assay::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.assay", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.assay::statistician", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.assay", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.timepoint::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.timepoint", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.timepoint::statistician", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.timepoint", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.scale_and_direction::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.scale_and_direction", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.scale_and_direction::statistician", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.scale_and_direction", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.standardization_reference::experimental_lead", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.standardization_reference", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "primary_functional_endpoint.standardization_reference::statistician", "field_path": "primary_functional_endpoint.standardization_reference", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "operating_characteristic_inputs.empirical_residual_sd::statistician", "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.empirical_residual_sd", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "operating_characteristic_inputs.between_pair_heterogeneity_sd::statistician", "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.between_pair_heterogeneity_sd", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "operating_characteristic_inputs.delta_delta_variance_multiplier::statistician", "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.delta_delta_variance_multiplier", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "operating_characteristic_inputs.equivalence_margin::statistician", "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.equivalence_margin", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "operating_characteristic_inputs.minimum_guide_retention_probability::statistician", "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.minimum_guide_retention_probability", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "operating_characteristic_inputs.target_concordant_probability::statistician", "field_path": "operating_characteristic_inputs.target_concordant_probability", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_complete_guides_per_pair::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_complete_guides_per_pair", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_complete_guides_per_pair::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_complete_guides_per_pair", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_independent_differentiations_per_genotype_pair::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_independent_differentiations_per_genotype_pair", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_independent_differentiations_per_genotype_pair::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.minimum_independent_differentiations_per_genotype_pair", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.engagement_rule::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.engagement_rule", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.engagement_rule::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.engagement_rule", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.positive_control_rule::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.positive_control_rule", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.positive_control_rule::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.positive_control_rule", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.cell_support_rule::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.cell_support_rule", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.cell_support_rule::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.cell_support_rule", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.missing_pair_rule::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.missing_pair_rule", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.missing_pair_rule::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.missing_pair_rule", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.adverse_effect_rule::experimental_lead", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.adverse_effect_rule", "role_id": "experimental_lead", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "qc_and_missingness.adverse_effect_rule::statistician", "field_path": "qc_and_missingness.adverse_effect_rule", "role_id": "statistician", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "outcome_access.required_external_freeze_receipt_id::outcome_access_custodian", "field_path": "outcome_access.required_external_freeze_receipt_id", "role_id": "outcome_access_custodian", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" }, { "assignment_key": "outcome_access.access_custodian::outcome_access_custodian", "field_path": "outcome_access.access_custodian", "role_id": "outcome_access_custodian", "decision_state": "PENDING", "signature_effect": "NONE" } ], "field_review_states": [ "PENDING", "ACCEPT_FOR_HANDOFF", "REVISE_BEFORE_HANDOFF" ], "handoff_states": [ "NOT_REVIEWABLE", "PENDING_FIELD_REVIEW", "WARNING_ADJUDICATION_REQUIRED", "REVISION_REQUESTED", "READY_FOR_EXTERNAL_SIGNATURE" ], "role_packet_schema": "nmd-vcell-adam10-authority-review-packet/1.0", "role_packet_count_required": 3, "role_packet_states": [ "NOT_REVIEWABLE", "ROLE_PACKETS_PENDING", "PACKET_VALIDATION_FAILED", "REVISION_REQUESTED", "READY_FOR_EXTERNAL_SIGNATURE" ], "role_packet_merge_policy": { "exact_review_base_sha256_required": true, "exact_role_assignment_set_required": true, "packet_sha256_required": true, "pending_decisions_permitted": false, "conflicting_local_review": "REJECT_PACKET_ATOMICALLY", "signature_effect": "NONE", "registration_effect": "NONE", "formal_unlocks": [] }, "semantic_check_count": 15, "semantic_checks": [ { "check_id": "AUTHORITY_APPROVAL_DATES_ISO", "severity": "error", "operator": "iso_date", "field_paths": [ "authorities.experimental_lead_approval_date", "authorities.statistician_approval_date" ], "message": "Authority approval dates must use valid YYYY-MM-DD calendar dates." }, { "check_id": "AUTHORITY_APPROVAL_DATES_NOT_FUTURE", "severity": "error", "operator": "date_not_future", "field_paths": [ "authorities.experimental_lead_approval_date", "authorities.statistician_approval_date" ], "message": "Authority approval dates cannot be later than the validation date." }, { "check_id": "MODEL_PAIR_IDS_UNIQUE", "severity": "error", "operator": "unique_case_insensitive", "field_paths": [ "model_pairs.0.pair_id", "model_pairs.1.pair_id" ], "message": "The two independent model pairs must have distinct pair identifiers." }, { "check_id": "MODEL_LINE_IDENTIFIERS_UNIQUE", "severity": "error", "operator": "unique_case_insensitive", "field_paths": [ "model_pairs.0.dmd_line_identifier", "model_pairs.0.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier", "model_pairs.1.dmd_line_identifier", "model_pairs.1.isogenic_corrected_line_identifier" ], "message": "DMD and corrected line identifiers must be distinct across both independent model pairs." }, { "check_id": "EMPIRICAL_RESIDUAL_SD_POSITIVE", "severity": "error", "operator": "number_compare", "field_paths": [ "operating_characteristic_inputs.empirical_residual_sd" ], "comparison": "greater_than", "threshold": 0, "message": "Empirical residual SD must be a finite value greater than zero." }, { "check_id": "BETWEEN_PAIR_HETEROGENEITY_NONNEGATIVE", "severity": "error", "operator": "number_compare", "field_paths": [ "operating_characteristic_inputs.between_pair_heterogeneity_sd" ], "comparison": "greater_than_or_equal", "threshold": 0, "message": "Between-pair heterogeneity SD must be finite and non-negative." }, { "check_id": "DELTA_DELTA_VARIANCE_MULTIPLIER_POSITIVE", "severity": "error", "operator": "number_compare", "field_paths": [ "operating_characteristic_inputs.delta_delta_variance_multiplier" ], "comparison": "greater_than", "threshold": 0, "message": "The DeltaDelta variance multiplier must be finite and greater than zero." }, { "check_id": "EQUIVALENCE_MARGIN_POSITIVE", "severity": "error", "operator": "number_compare", "field_paths": [ "operating_characteristic_inputs.equivalence_margin" ], "comparison": "greater_than", "threshold": 0, "message": "The equivalence margin must be finite and greater than zero on the frozen endpoint scale." }, { "check_id": "GUIDE_RETENTION_PROBABILITY_RANGE", "severity": "error", "operator": "number_range", "field_paths": [ "operating_characteristic_inputs.minimum_guide_retention_probability" ], "minimum": 0, "maximum": 1, "minimum_inclusive": false, "maximum_inclusive": true, "message": "Minimum guide-retention probability must be in (0, 1]." }, { "check_id": "TARGET_CONCORDANT_PROBABILITY_RANGE", "severity": "error", "operator": "number_range", "field_paths": [ "operating_characteristic_inputs.target_concordant_probability" ], "minimum": 0, "maximum": 1, "minimum_inclusive": false, "maximum_inclusive": true, "message": "Target concordant probability must be in (0, 1]." }, { "check_id": "MINIMUM_COMPLETE_GUIDES_INTEGER", "severity": "error", "operator": "integer_greater_than_or_equal", "field_paths": [ "qc_and_missingness.minimum_complete_guides_per_pair" ], "threshold": 1, "message": "Minimum complete guides per pair must be an integer of at least one." }, { "check_id": "MINIMUM_DIFFERENTIATIONS_INTEGER", "severity": "error", "operator": "integer_greater_than_or_equal", "field_paths": [ "qc_and_missingness.minimum_independent_differentiations_per_genotype_pair" ], "threshold": 1, "message": "Minimum independent differentiations must be an integer of at least one." }, { "check_id": "EXTERNAL_FREEZE_RECEIPT_SPECIFICITY", "severity": "warning", "operator": "minimum_text_length", "field_paths": [ "outcome_access.required_external_freeze_receipt_id" ], "threshold": 8, "message": "The external freeze receipt identifier is unusually short; confirm that it resolves unambiguously." }, { "check_id": "PRIMARY_ENDPOINT_IDENTITIES_DISTINCT", "severity": "warning", "operator": "different_case_insensitive", "field_paths": [ "primary_molecular_endpoint.name", "primary_functional_endpoint.name" ], "message": "Molecular and functional endpoint names are identical; confirm that two genuinely distinct endpoint roles were intended." }, { "check_id": "EVIDENCE_RECEIPT_SCOPE_REVIEW", "severity": "warning", "operator": "evidence_max_reuse", "field_paths": [], "threshold": 10, "message": "One evidence receipt is reused for more than ten fields; confirm that its documented scope covers every linked parameter." } ], "storage_policy": { "server_persistence": false, "browser_local_storage": true, "network_submission": false, "export_is_user_initiated": true }, "readiness_states": [ "BLOCKED_INCOMPLETE", "INPUTS_COMPLETE_PROVENANCE_INCOMPLETE", "SEMANTIC_REVIEW_FAILED", "REVIEW_READY_WITH_WARNINGS_AWAITING_EXTERNAL_REGISTRATION", "REVIEW_READY_AWAITING_EXTERNAL_REGISTRATION" ], "prohibited_transitions": [ "automatic wet-lab authorization", "automatic randomization generation", "automatic study registration", "automatic outcome access" ], "formal_unlocks": [], "claim_boundary": "This interface only prepares a local review dossier. Completion does not register the amendment, authorize wet-lab work, generate assignments or permit outcome access." }